When summer arrives in Buffalo, NY, nothing beats the heat quite like a scoop (or two) of ice cream. Jeremy and Nia, avid ice cream enthusiasts, have spent countless summer days exploring the city’s best spots for this beloved treat. Here, they share their top four local favorites that offer a unique blend of flavors, history, and charm.
1. Anderson’s Ice Cream
Location: Multiple locations, including 6075 Main St, Williamsville, NY
Anderson’s Ice Cream is a Buffalo institution, serving up delicious frozen treats since 1946. Jeremy and Nia love Anderson’s for its classic custards and wide range of flavors, including their famous seasonal offerings. The rich, creamy texture and nostalgic atmosphere make Anderson’s a go-to for anyone craving a traditional ice cream experience. Jeremy’s favorite is the black raspberry, while Nia can’t resist the butter pecan.
2. Pautler’s Drive-In on Transit
Location: 6343 Transit Rd., East Amherst, NY
Pautler’s Drive-In isn’t just about ice cream – it’s an experience. Nestled on Transit Road, this charming drive-in has been a summer staple for families in the area. Jeremy and Nia appreciate the old-school vibe and the extensive menu that offers more than just ice cream. After enjoying a juicy burger and crispy fries, they indulge in one of Pautler’s signature sundaes. The hot fudge sundae, topped with whipped cream and a cherry, is a crowd favorite and a perfect way to end a meal.
3. Churn on Hertel
Location: 1501 Hertel Ave., Buffalo, NY
Churn on Hertel is a relatively new addition to Buffalo’s ice cream scene, but it has quickly become a favorite for Jeremy and Nia. This trendy spot is known for its innovative flavors and artisanal approach. Each visit to Churn is an adventure, with unique options like honey lavender, chocolate stout, and vegan coconut chocolate chip. The modern, vibrant atmosphere adds to the experience, making it a perfect spot for a summer evening out.
4. Sweet Jennies in the Old Red Mill
Location: 56 E Spring St., Williamsville, NY
Stepping into Sweet Jennies is like taking a step back in time. Housed in the historic Old Red Mill, this charming ice cream parlor offers a delightful mix of traditional and creative flavors. Jeremy and Nia love the sense of history and the cozy feel of the place. The homemade ice cream is simply divine, with flavors like salted caramel pretzel and blueberry cheesecake capturing their hearts. The rustic setting, complete with wooden beams and old-fashioned decor, makes every visit a memorable one.
5. Lake Effect Ice Cream
Location: 1900 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY
Lake Effect Ice Cream is a gem in the Buffalo area known for its creative and locally-inspired flavors. Jeremy and Nia adore Lake Effect for its dedication to using high-quality ingredients and crafting unique combinations. Some of their favorites include the Frozen Hot Chocolate and Paula’s Glazed Donut, which reflect the local culture and tastes. The Lockport location’s canal-side setting provides a scenic backdrop, perfect for enjoying a scoop on a warm day.
Conclusion
Buffalo’s ice cream scene offers a delightful array of choices, each with its own unique charm and flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic treat at Anderson’s, a retro experience at Pautler’s Drive-In, an innovative scoop at Churn, a historic visit to Sweet Jennies, or a creative flavor at Lake Effect, there’s something for every ice cream lover. Jeremy and Nia’s adventures highlight the sweet spots that make Buffalo a fantastic place to explore and enjoy ice cream. Next time you’re in the area, be sure to visit these local gems and treat yourself to the best scoops in town.
